材料科学领域专利审查时有关创造性判断的技术分析
Technical Analysis about the Inventive Step in Patent Examination in Material Science Field

作者: 马彩霞 , 王祖鹓 , 潘惠 :国家知识产权局专利局材料工程发明审查部,北京; 薛永兵 :太原科技大学化学与生物工程学院,太原;

关键词: 专利审查创造性技术分析材料领域Patent Examination Inventive Step Technical Analysis Material Field

摘要:
在国内外的专利审查中,创造性的判断一直是实质审查工作中的难点和争议点。本文通过材料科学领域的真实案例,从发明与对比文件的区别点、发明实际要解决的技术问题、对比文件给出的技术启示的判断以及预料不到的技术效果等方面对创造性的判断进行了技术分析,思考和总结了专利审查中有关创造性判断中需要注意的问题,有助于进一步全面、客观地进行创造性判断和审查,也为专利申请人和科技工作者撰写和申请专利提供参考和借鉴。
>It is always difficult and controversial to estimate and evaluate the inventive step in patent examination all over the world. Through true patent cases in material science field, this article technically analyzed the inventive step from the differences between inventions and comparing files, objective technical problems of inventions that need to be solved, and technical inspiration and unexpected technical effects of comparing files. Thinking and summarizing issues of inventive step that might need attention in patent examination helped to further estimate and evaluate the inventive step generally and objectively. Some advices were proposed to provide references for patent applicant and scientific and technical workers’ composing and applying for patents.

文章引用: 马彩霞 , 薛永兵 , 王祖鹓 , 潘惠 (2013) 材料科学领域专利审查时有关创造性判断的技术分析。 材料科学, 3, 216-221. doi: 10.12677/MS.2013.35039

参考文献

[1] 中华人民共和国国家知识产权局.专利审查指南2010[M]. 北京: 知识产权出版社, 2010.

[2] 平野兼次. 排气净化用催化剂和排气净化催化剂构件[P]. 中国专利: 200680050752, 2006.

[3] H. Uchida. Catalyst for removal of nitrogen oxides by decompo- sition and method. Japanese Patent: 2011-342336A, 2011.

[4] 宋卫国, 江雷, 崔志民等. 一种保护具有微米和/或纳米多级结构催化剂方法[P]. 中国专利: 201110025318.1, 2011-08-03.

[5] 张磊, 乔世璋, 阎子峰等. 界面组装控制的碳纳米管/有序介孔氧化硅核壳纳米线[J]. 科学通报, 2008, 53(17): 2104-2108.

[6] G. Shen, Y. Bando, C. Lee, et al. Growth of self-organized hier- archical ZnO nanoarchitectures by a simple In/In2S3 controlled thermal evaporation process. The Journal of Physical Chemistry B, 2005, 109(21): 10779-10785.

分享
Top